Home
Loading
  Letters to the Editor     About Us     Contact Us    
The Google Philharmonic

Why orchestras should take a page out of Google's business philosophy handbook.

by Holly Mulcahy
December 7, 2009

Bookmark and Share
The Google Philharmonic

A few months back I published an article that examined elements from Geoff Colvin's book, Talent is Overrated. One of Colvin's key points was how companies cultivate creativity and then use it to create better and more productive employees. Colvin used Google as one of his examples and wrote extensively about their philosophy behind fostering a very employee-friendly work environment and how it promotes and maintains productivity.

Colvin's example made me want to learn even more about Google. They provide so much to workers, I was secretly hoping to find an in-house orchestra in which I could apply. Among the list of benefits Google offers employees is free organic cuisine, excellent health care benefits, the ability to bring dogs to the office, the list goes on. But one of my favorite benefits was their 20% of work time per week in which engineers are allowed to use for whatever projects they are passionate about. For Google, the 20% time has allowed for employees to come up with some of Google's most popular added features as well as finding new ways of making Google's service better, faster, and more fun.

After returning Talent is Overrated to my library, I checked out The Google Story by David A. Vise. In this book, readers are guided through Google's life (or at least up through when the book was published) to see why Google goes to great lengths to treat their employees so well. Throughout the book, I kept wondering why orchestras can't adopt some of these principles.

A dispensable cog in an irrelevant wheel.

For the benefit of those who may not be familiar with an orchestra musician's workplace, it isn't uncommon for openings to attract dozens or even hundreds of applicants. In one of my instances, after competing with more than 100 other violinists for a single position as "section first violin," I felt pretty good. I had just won a decent, full-time orchestra job that 99 other violinists desperately wanted. Like so many other musicians that succeed in auditions, the experience made me feel useful, necessary, needed, and wanted in that orchestra. But within a month of starting the position, it became clear that my outlook was misplaced and my feelings of being a contributing member of the organization were replaced by feeling expendable. All too frequently, I was even told that "You can and will be easily replaced."

It wasn't just me, most of my musician colleagues and even staff members were made to feel marginalized after beginning their jobs with the orchestra. And the repeating stanza of "You can and will be easily replaced" reinforces feelings of indifference. Protests are frequently met with a hostile lack of concern from upper management.

"You do know there are over 100 people that want your job, don't you?," said one of my former upper managers. "It is simple supply and demand and you simply aren't valuable, so shut up."

I know from experience, both musicians and staff are very passionate about their job. They want to help make things better but all too often, offers of help or suggestions are pushed aside by upper management as quickly as a child can be dismissed at a dinner conversation. This only fosters a relationship that has one side blaming the other for everything bad that happens. Needless to say, any feeling of joint ownership is demolished in this sort of workplace.  This only motivates musicians to audition elsewhere, and encourages talented staff to interview for other positions where they may feel useful.

Reading Vise's book made it simple to understand the reason Google goes out of its way to treat employees so well: they want to keep the talent they find. As Vice points out, it's not just the outstanding benefits and pay that contributes to Google's employee's job satisfaction, it's a creative outlet that actually matters to the worker and the company. And in turn, workers are less inclined to leave, the talent stays within Google, and they build a stronger company as a whole.

Of course, comparing a nonprofit arts system to a Fortune 500 company might seem a bit silly. After all, no orchestra will have the sort of money available to replicate all of the benefits Google offers. But taking certain aspects of the Google philosophy to heart in creating the work culture would definitely create a stronger and healthier symphony orchestra.

Keeping talent in an orchestra should be at the top of the list in mission goals. It goes beyond money, although that really helps. So often, upper management forgets that beyond a paycheck, there is purpose and pride involved in cultivating a happy and productive employee.

What would happen if an overworked symphony staff was presented with some choices like Google offers? Would they devote 20% of their time to finding solutions to institutional problems using their own creativity? Could they better use a whole Friday walking around their child's school talking to teachers at lunch break about the new daddy-daughter concert their co-worker dreamed up on their 20% time?

What about the musician whose time at work is split between 25 hour week of rehearsals and 20+ hours of home practice? Could they benefit or even want to partake in a 20% time? It might be harder, but I'd bet if a musician could take off an "in-school" concert to play their own recital at a legal office lunch hour, there might be some takers.

I've experienced situations where managers have offered some flexibility with employee sponsored projects but in each of these cases it has been held out as a limited offering. Only a handful of musicians were allowed to pursue personal projects and they were made to pitch ideas that upper managers selected. All this did was create resentment among musicians and after a short time, the only musicians pitching ideas were those who had projects selected earlier.

There is no simple fix to the melancholy I see in various orchestral groups. Money is obviously in short supply, but in order to push through these modern day challenges, some good old fashion creativity needs to start somewhere.

Comments (1)


Post a Comment

Milena Thomas from MI writes:
December 28, 2009
I think the 20% creative time at work is particularly important. I will keep these things in mind if I ever have employees one day. The Google model really helps explain why it is such an obvious success story.

Send Us Your Opinion
(Comments are moderated.)
Your Name:*


Your E-Mail Address:*
(Confidential. Will not be published.)


Location:


Comments:*
Note: In order to control automated spam submissions, URLs are no longer permitted in this form.



  Printer-Friendly

Bookmark and Share

» hollymulcahy@partialobserver.com


RSS FEED
RSS Feed for Neo Classical: RSS Feed for Holly Mulcahy
EMAIL ALERTS
Sign up to receive an e-mail notice when new articles by this author are published. Your address remains confidential, and you may cancel at any time. A confirmation email will be sent.

Your e-mail address:
po Books
Now Available!

Teachings of a Three Year Old... Turned Tyke,
by Hal Evan Caplan.

A father learns from the wisdom of his toddler.

More Information.

More by Holly Mulcahy
Starting Next Month, Neo Classical Will Have A New Home
It has been six wonderful years at The Partial Observer.
by Holly Mulcahy, 9/6/10
Speaking The Unspeakable
A slip of the tongue helps maintain vigilance.
by Holly Mulcahy, 8/2/10
Orchestra Etiquette Part II
A view through the centuries on proper behavior.
by Holly Mulcahy, 7/5/10
Orchestra Etiquette Part I
A view through the centuries on proper behavior.
by Holly Mulcahy, 6/7/10
Lambs to Slaughter
Eroding the value of mentoring programs.
by Holly Mulcahy, 5/3/10
It's Black and White
The hidden effects of cutting corners
by Holly Mulcahy, 4/5/10
Orchestra Smaland
What a Swedish mega-retailer can teach classical music about building a customer base.
by Holly Mulcahy, 3/1/10
» Complete List (39)


RSS FEED
RSS Feed for Neo Classical: RSS Feed for Holly Mulcahy

Recently Published
View Article The Kingdom Restored
How King Jesus deposed an imposter called death
by Greg Asimakoupoulos, 4/18/14
A Personal Look at Palm Sunday
What the eyes of faith reveal
by Greg Asimakoupoulos, 4/11/14
Paying college athletes?
Unleash the boosters and allow athletes to market themselves
by James Leroy Wilson, 4/8/14
The Tulips Trumpet an Easter Tune
The Skagit Valley offers hope to the heartbroken of Oso
by Greg Asimakoupoulos, 4/4/14
Ryan Braun's Standing O
Is playing by the rules still important?
by James Leroy Wilson, 4/1/14
A Prayer for Oso
Calling on the Creator for those impacted by the mudslide
by Greg Asimakoupoulos, 3/28/14
Clueless Leadership
How hierarchy leads to bad outcomes in sports and politics
by James Leroy Wilson, 3/25/14

Get the Partial Observer's
'recently published' headlines via RSS.


RSS Feed for Recently Published PO Articles    What is RSS?
Reproduction of original material from The Partial Observer without written permission is strictly prohibited.
The opinions expressed by site contributors do not necessarily reflect those of the editors.
Copyright ©2000-2014 partialobserver.com. All rights reserved.
Home · Site Map · Top